The DHS Program User Forum: India » Change in age of women for domestic violence module

Home » Countries » India » Change in age of women for domestic violence module

Show: Today's Messages :: Show Polls :: Message Navigator

Change in age of women for domestic violence module [message #27500]

Wed, 23 August 2023 12:57

dcpathak
Messages: 8
Registered: September 2022

Member

Hi,
The age of women covered in the domestic violence module has changed from 15-49 years (as in NFHS-4) to 18-49 years in NFHS-5. Could you tell me the logic behind this change? Furthermore, can I compare state-level estimates of domestic violence from NFHS-4 by accounting for only women in the 18-49 age group with those in NFHS-5?
Thanks in anticipation,
Durgesh

Report message to a moderator

Re: Change in age of women for domestic violence module [message #27504 is a reply to message #27500]

Thu, 24 August 2023 10:13

fred.arnold@icf.com is currently offline

fred.arnold@icf.com
Messages: 84
Registered: May 2021

Senior Member

You are correct that NFHS-5 includes only women age 18-49 in the domestic violence section of the woman's questionnaire. Women age 15-17 were not included. There is a clear and compelling reason that this decision was made. The Government of India has a law called the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POSCO) Act. The Act focuses on children, which includes anyone under 18 years of age. The act requires anyone who comes to know about a child who was a victim of a sexual offence to promptly contact the police and provide them with that information. If women age 15-17 had been included in the domestic violence section of the NFHS-5 questionnaire, the interviewer would be required by law to promptly inform the police of any instances of sexual violence based on the respondent's answers to the domestic violence questions. Any interviewer who did not contact the police in such a circumstance would be liable to prosecution under the law. If the interviewer informed the implementing agency about this situation, then the implementing agency would also be liable to prosecution if the police were not informed.

Informing the police about instances of sexual violence would not be ethical for the following reasons:
1. The informed consent statement at the beginning of the woman's questionnaire indicates that "All of the answer you give will be confidential and will not be shared with anyone other than members of our survey team. Under the circumstances, informing the police about instances of sexual violence would violate that assurance and would be unethical.
2. Breaching the standard assurance of confidentiality clause in NFHS-5 if the police were contacted would also violate the NFHS-5 policy documents that were provided to the Institutional Review Board committee for review.

The NFHS-5 final report (Page 642) indicates that comparisons over time cannot be made for women age 18-49. Although it would be possible to make comparisons of domestic violence between NFHS-4 and NFHS-5 for women age 18-49 by excluding women age 15-17 from NFHS-4, any comparative analysis for women age 18-49 should be clearly explained in the text.

Report message to a moderator

Re: Change in age of women for domestic violence module [message #27511 is a reply to message #27504]

Sat, 26 August 2023 02:21

dcpathak
Messages: 8
Registered: September 2022

Member

Thanks for the detailed reply. I noticed the instruction on p. 642 of the Report about the comparison. My hunch was that I could compare those in the 18-49 age group over these two surveys, and I need to clearly indicate that the 15-17 age group has been dropped for the NFHS-4. Your reply also implies the same (please correct me if I am not getting it right).
Thanks again for the clarification.
Regards,
Dcpathak

Report message to a moderator

Previous Topic:	FAMILY STRUCTURE
Next Topic:	which state does v101 equal to 37 represent in India data?

Goto Forum:

-=] Back to Top [=-

[ Syndicate this forum (XML) ] [

] [

]

Current Time: Wed Dec 3 23:37:46 Coordinated Universal Time 2025